“And let us consider how we may spur one another on toward love and good deeds, not giving up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but encouraging one another—and all the more as you see the Day approaching.” — Hebrews 10:24-25

Rev. James Panza

Lead Pastor

James is the Lead Pastor at Grace Chapel. He came to know the Lord as a young teenager and has been serving the Lord for nearly 25 years. He has known Gods call on his life ever since. He has attended Southeastern University and Berean/Global University.

James has served as a Worship Leader at Zarephath Christian Church in Zarephath, New Jersey.  For 15 years prior to that he served as an Associate Pastor and Worship Leader at Flemington Assembly of God Church in Flemington, New Jersey. He also was a successful business owner/operator throughout the course of these ministry callings.

James has also spent time on numerous national and overseas missions and has developed a Worship Ministry affectionately known as the "James Gang" that still serves and is available for various functions, events, conferences and special services. His desire is that people get to an intimate place with Jesus through worship and prayer.

James has been happily married for over 24 years to his wife Cindy and has four children: Caleb, Josiah, Bethany and Hope. His family serves in partnership with him and strengthens his role and ability to function in ministry.

As a Pastor at Grace, his passion is to see the church continue its role and responsibility to love and serve the local, national and world communities that need to know that the power, mercy and love of Jesus is relevant and needed for them today.  Click here to listen to Pastor James review his Sunday Sermons!

 Email Pastor James


Frankie Pavia

Pastor of Student Ministries

Frankie grew up in Rockaway Beach, NY with his mother and two older sisters.  He has a Bachelor of Arts degree in Biblical Studies from Pillar College and soon will complete a Masters in Global Studies from Liberty University. His wife, Keyla, serves Pillar College full-time as the VP of Institutional Outreach.  

Both Frankie and Keyla have passionate hearts for young people and the Church as a whole.  Frankie states,  “I am passionate about being able to help shape and mold a generation that will become the next group of believers that can shake the world. I firmly believe that God calls even the youngest children to be workers in the Kingdom, and if we can assist in any way, it would be by making ourselves available to teach and disciple our children to lead a life which is pleasing to God.” 

With Frankies leading, they will tackle the critical task of developing and building strong  Jr. High outreach and discipleship ministries that undergird our current Sr. High ministry while providing depth for the future.  

Frankie and Keyla were blessed with a son, Evan, in August of 2013 and are excited about their new ministry work here at Grace.

 Email Pastor Frankie


Traci Otalora

Church Administrator

Traci came to know the Lord as her Savior as a young child growing up in Long Hill Chapel in Chatham. She has a Bachelors Degree in Business Management from Fairleigh Dickinson University in Madison, NJ.    

For over 20 years, while raising her children, Traci served in her home church in many capacities such as; Deaconess, Board Member, Church Clerk, Ladies Bible Study Leader, Day Camp Art Director, Little Lambs Christian Nursery School Teacher, AWANA Secretary and singer on the Worship team. 

She has two daughters, Brittany and Rebecca, a son-in-law (Joe), and is thrilled to now be a part of Grace Chapel of Bedminster.

 Email Traci



Tara Mezzasalma

C.E. Director

Tara came to know the Lord at a young age, in her church’s Sunday School program. Knowing first hand the impact Sunday School has had on her life, she is passionate about working to “Train up a child in the way he should go," knowing the promise of God is sure that "...even when he is old he will not depart from it.”  Proverbs 22:6

Tara has always had a passion for working with and educating children. Upon graduating with her bachelor’s degree in Elementary Education from Montclair State University she was hired as a third grade teacher in Short Hills, NJ where she has worked for seven years. While teaching in Short Hills she lead teacher trainings and helped develop district wide curriculum.

Before becoming a public school teacher she worked at New Kids Daycare Center in Belleville, NJ and later at the Montclair State University Children’s Center. Since age 13 she has been a volunteer in various children’s ministries, including a mission trip to an orphanage in Uganda, Africa. 

Tara is happily married to John and has been blessed with three children Caleb, Olivia and Leo. She is currently taking time off from teaching to be a stay-at-home mother.

 Email Tara

Grace Chapel

375 Main Street
Bedminster, NJ 07921
P: 908.719.1093

Driving Directions Send us an email Listen to the latest sermon Like Us on Facebook